IN MAY 1870 QUOGUE STATION OPENED JUST WEST OF LEWIS ROAD IT WAS MOST LIKELY ONLY A PLATFORM NORTH OF THE TRACK.
VINCENT SEYFRIED WROTE:
IN JUNE AND JULY 1875 QUOGUE WAS MOVED WEST AND ATLANTICVILLE STATION OPENED HERE. PARCEL THREE WAS OBTAINED IN JULY 1875. BILL SLADE PLACES THE STATION AT 77 MILES.
THIS IS A BRAINERD PHOTO WITH NO IDENTIFICATION. WE BELIEVE IT IS ATLANTICVILLE. IT SHOWS LEWIS ROAD CROSSING AND A FENCE ALONG THE OLD LINE OF MAIN COUNTRY ROAD WHICH HAD BEEN REROUTED AROUND THE STATION.
BROOKLYN PUBLIC LIBRARY
SEYFRIED STATES THAT A BUILDING WAS CONSTRUCTED AT LEWIS ROAD, ORIGINAL SITE OF QUOGUE STATION, IN JUNE AND JULY 1875 AND STATION APPEARS IN SEPTEMBER TIMETABLE.
THIS IS OCTOBER 21 1875 WITH THANKS TO BOB RICKEY
OCTOBER 23 1876
1877
ATLANTICVILLE APPEARS ALSO IN 1877, JULY 1880 AND JULY 1881 TIMETABLES.
JULY 1880
JULY 1881
A JULY 6 1880 AD
THIS 1882 - 1884 MAP SHOWS ATLANTICVILLE STATION
THE AUTHOR OF AN 1884 ARTICLE RODE A TRAIN TO QUOGUE AND FROM THERE A STAGE TO ATLANTICVILLE.
THIS LATER MAP SHOWS QUOGUE STATION AND ATLANTICVILLE HAMLET
A SEPTEMBER 11 1886 AD
IN APRIL 1891 THE POST OFFICE CHANGED THE NAME OF ATLANTICVILLE TO EAST QUOGUE
AND QUOGUE WAS MOVED ONE AND ONE-FIFTH MILES TO THE WEST. PARCELS TWELVE AND FOURTEEN WERE OBTAINED IN MAY 1875. BILL SLADE PLACES THE STATION AT 75.8 MILES.
GEORGE BRADFORD BRAINERD 1879 PHOTO LOOKING WEST
BROOKLYN PUBLIC LIBRARY
VARIOUS SOURCES HAVE SAID THAT QUOGUE STATION WAS STOLEN, MOVED, REMOVED, KIDNAPPED, THROWN INTO THE WOODS AND OTHERWISE DISAPPEARED.
HERE'S THE STORY:
IN 1882 ATLANTICVILLE WAS CLOSED - QUOGUE STATION BUILDING WAS SURREPTITIOUSLY MOVED SIX TENTHS OF A MILE EAST TO A LOCATION HALF WAY BETWEEN THE STATIONS.
A MARCH 18 1882 BABYLON SIGNAL ARTICLE
A MAY 27 1882 BABYLON SIGNAL ARTICLE
PARCELS THREE AND FIVE WERE OBTAINED IN APRIL 1882.
THIS IS THE 1905 STATION. BILL SLADE PLACES THE STATION AT 76.4 MILES.
DAVE KELLER OFFERS HIS BELIEF THAT THE 1875 STATION, MOVED HERE IN 1882, WAS PLACED EAST OF THE GRADE CROSSING TOWARD THE EAST END OF PARCEL FIVE AND CAN BE SEEN IN OSBORNE'S 1925 PHOTOGRAPH. WE CONCUR
J. V. OSBORNE c 1925
ON JULY 29 1882 THE SIGNAL ANNOUNCED "MISS CARRIE A. FLETCHER WILL SHAPE THE DESTINIES OF THE TICKET AND TELEGRAPH OFFICES AT QUOGUE FOR AN INDEFINITE PERIOD".
AS LATE AS SEPTEMBER 1897 PEOPLE IN ATLANTICVILLE WANTED THEIR STATION BACK. BROOKLYN DALY EAGLE